Science Gone Astray: Evolution and Rape

Authors

Elisabeth A. Lloyd, Indiana University, Bloomington

Abstract

Throughout A Natural History of Rape, coauthors Randy Thomhill and Craig Palmer resort to what is known among philosophers of science as "The Galileo Defense," which amounts to the following claim: I am telling the Truth and doing excellent science, but because of ideology and ignorance, I am being persecuted. The authors have repeated and elaborated upon this defense during the si:lable media flurry accompanying the book's publication in February 2000. Now, history has accepted this defense from Galileo. But in order for it to work for Thornhill and Palmer, of course, they must be telling the Truth and doing excellent science. In this Review I shall argue that the Galileo defense is impotent in the hands of Thornhill and Palmer because of glaring flaws in their science.

Recommended Citation

Elisabeth A. Lloyd, Science Gone Astray: Evolution and Rape, 99 Mich. L. Rev. 1536 (2001).
Available at: https://repository.law.umich.edu/mlr/vol99/iss6/17