Science and Politics in Public Health Regulation

Document Type

Article

Publication Date

2025

Abstract

This essay challenges the common framing of regulation as a choice between "science" and "politics." Through an examination of contemporary public health controversies, the essay demonstrates that the decision to defer to scientific expertise is itself inherently political, requiring democratic justification and accountability. The essay makes three main contributions. First, it shows how even supposedly "pure" scientific decisions in public health regulation invariably involve value judgments and policy choices. Second, it argues that delegation to scientific experts can serve rather than impede democratic goals, particularly when the public seeks to address complex, evolving problems that require specialized knowledge. The essay examines how Congress has repeatedly chosen to empower scientific decision-makers through various institutional mechanisms while maintaining democratic accountability. But third, the essay also identifies significant democratic risks in deferring to scientific expertise. These include the tendency of specialized agencies to become distant from ordinary citizens, the risk that scientific disciplines may systematically undervalue certain public concerns, and the problem of public health paternalism that can erode trust and accountability. Rather than responding to these challenges through additional procedural requirements that might further hamper effective regulation, the essay suggests institutional reforms to promote transparency, deliberation, and meaningful democratic oversight of scientific decision-making.

The essay concludes that the key question is not whether to choose science or politics, but how to design institutional arrangements that allow scientific expertise to advance democratic goals while maintaining appropriate accountability. This analysis has implications beyond public health regulation, offering insights for administrative law and democratic theory more broadly.

Link to Full Text

Share

COinS