Document Type

Article

Publication Date

2026

Abstract

“Judge Kozinski Objects”1 was the first “real” article I wrote as a law professor. I was really proud of it. But when the editors of Legal Communication & Rhetoric asked me if I would write a reflection on it for this volume, I felt conflicted. I struggle with how I should view “Judge Kozinski Objects” in light of the subsequent revelations about Kozinski’s sexual harassment of judicial clerks, law students, colleagues, and other women over his several decades on the federal bench. My own struggle mirrors the conversation that regularly arises when a powerful man is outed for his misdeeds: How should we relate to and use—or reject—the professional work of a disgraced sexual harasser? It turns out that when the sexual harasser is a former federal judge, the answer to that question is made more complicated by how our judicial system works—and especially by the interplay between precedent, lawyering, and judicial credibility.

Comments

Originally published as Wilensky, Beth H. "Judge Kozinski Objects: A Reflection." Legal Comm. & Rhetoric: JALWD 23 (2026): 1-11. Reproduced with permission.


Share

COinS